Leadership

How to Fight Toxic Positivity and Build a Trusting Workplace

Michelle D. Reines ·

Leadership

How to Fight Toxic Positivity and Build a Trusting Workplace

Many leaders fall into the trap of toxic positivity — glossing over real challenges and leaving employees feeling unheard. Authentic, transparent communication is what actually builds trust.

M
Michelle D. Reines
2 min read

Change is a constant in the workplace, and how organizations navigate it impacts employee trust, morale, and engagement. But many leaders fall into the trap of toxic positivity — ignoring or downplaying the real challenges and stress their teams face.

This toxic positivity can leave your employees feeling unheard and disengaged. And it definitely doesn't build a trusting workplace where people feel safe enough to share their concerns.

Research shows only 53% of employees feel comfortable expressing their feelings about change to executive leadership, compared to 78% who feel safer sharing with their managers or colleagues. Why? Because authentic, transparent communication builds trust while glossing over things creates barriers.

A culture of artificial harmony does not create sustainable improvement or foster collaboration. Toxic work environments are places where people become disengaged and disillusioned about their place and value in the organization.

Strategies for addressing change from an honest and supportive place:

Encourage honest feedback. Create safe spaces where employees feel empowered to share their concerns without fear of judgment or repercussions. Projecting a positive attitude about potentially destabilizing changes can ultimately undermine your goals and create more frustration than if you had acknowledged potential pain points to begin with.

Act on the feedback. Listening isn't enough — show employees that their input drives meaningful change.

Develop leadership skills. When managers and leaders are visible, empathetic, and accessible, employees are more likely to feel heard and valued.

Conduct regular check-ins. Managers play a critical role as intermediaries. Frequent, transparent conversations can help your teams navigate change with optimism and clarity.

These practices are especially important for managers, who are often caught in the middle and expected to keep an even keel. When managers are honest and transparent, it creates an environment where individual contributors feel safe to share their feelings.

Explore Topics

#trust#communication#culture#accountability
M

Written by

Michelle D. Reines

Content creator and writer sharing insights and stories.

More Insights

Leadership

Vulnerability in Leadership

For many leaders, there is an expectation that they always have all the answers. But this behavior is inauthentic and creates a false sense of harmony. Owning up to challenges and fostering honest dialogue builds trusting, cohesive teams.

Read more

Working through a leadership challenge?

Start a conversation with Michelle.

Let's Talk